Ace Metrix Reveals U.S. Consumers Top Ads of the Season

Nintendo, Ebates, Mazda and Amazon Achieve Breakout Scores While Retail Brands Fill-In Much of the Remaining List.

Ace Metrix has revealed the top scoring retail and cross-category holiday ads according to consumers in the U.S. Nintendo and Ebates maintained their early positions of number one and two throughout the season, outperforming their category peers by more than twenty percent. Advertisers used a variety of creative tools to capture consumer attention including heartwarming stories, charitable giving, festive humour and celebrity spokespeople.

“While unsurprisingly dominated by retail brands, an eclectic mix of advertisers demonstrated their creative savvy with ads rich in family and good cheer”

“While unsurprisingly dominated by retail brands, an eclectic mix of advertisers demonstrated their creative savvy with ads rich in family and good cheer,” said Peter Daboll, CEO of Ace Metrix. “Whether they drew their strength from standout breakthrough characteristics, connecting with consumers emotionally, imparting new information or leveraging product passion, the ads on this list represent the top performing three percent of all holiday ads to debut so far this year.”

Top Holiday Ads of 2014
Ranked by Percent Above Category Norm (YTD)


#	Brand Category	Ad Title	Ace Score	Category Norm	Percent Above Norm	Powered By

1	Nintendo Video Games	Dad Loses	630	511	23.2%	Breakthrough

2	Ebates.com Websites	Paid To Shop	610	500	21.9%	Information, Relevance, Desire

3	Mazda Corporate Branding	Braeden’s Story	690	569	21.2%	Emotion, Breakthrough

4	Amazon Fire TV Television Services	Rom-Coms	632	543	16.5%	Information, Change

5	Kohl’s Retail	Holiday Magic	640	550	16.3%	Emotion, Breakthrough

5	Walmart Retail	Surprise	640	550	16.3%	Emotion, Breakthrough

7	Subway QSR	Cool	670	579	15.7%	Information, Offer

8	Home Depot Retail	Spread More Of This	632	550	14.9%	Likeability, Relevance, Desire

8	PetSmart Retail	Thanks To Your Pets	632	550	14.9%	Emotion, Breakthrough

10	Nationwide Other Insurance	The Grinch And Santa	628	548	14.5%	Breakthrough

11	Coca-Cola Soda	Make Someone Happy	629	550	14.4%	Likeability, Relevance

12	Walmart Retail	Unbeatable Prices	629	550	14.3%	Relevance, Desire

13	Best Buy Retail	Light Up	625	550	13.6%	Breakthrough, Desire

13	Game Stop Retail	Santa’s Wish	625	550	13.6%	Breakthrough

15	Lowe’s Retail	Make Snowman	624	550	13.4%	Likeability, Relevance

*Definition: The Ace Score is the measure of ad creative performance based on viewer reaction to national TV ads. A unique sample of 500+ people, representative of the U.S. TV viewing audience, scores each ad. The results are presented on a scale of 1–950, which represents scoring on creative attributes such as Persuasion, Likeability, Information, Attention, Change, Relevance, Desire and Watchability. This list represents the top 15 holiday-themed ads whose scores outperformed their category year-to-date norms by the largest percentage. The list is based on ads to have debuted this season through December 15, 2014.

A Heartfelt (if not funny) Holiday

This year’s seasonal ads extended past the common theme of philanthropy with several advertisers delivering heartwarming stories of family and thoughtful giving. Mazda, Subaru, Blue Buffalo, Walmart and Target each debuted ads promoting a cause; however, Mazda’s “Braeden’s Story” and Walmart’s “Surprise” are the only philanthropic ads present in the top 15. Beyond philanthropic ads, brands such as Aleve, Coca-Cola, Dick’s, Kohl’s, Pampers and PetSmart portrayed uplifting themes that strived to make an emotional connection with consumers. And while overall, there were 40 percent less emotionally charged ads, this years heartwarming ads generated emotional sentiment scores 13 percent higher than last year’s set. In fact, of the top performing ads, four achieved Emotional Sentiment scores of 70 or higher (on an index of 100).

Humour also played a starring role this year with nearly 50 of all holiday ads attempting to be funny. Four of the top 15 ads were both funny and effective, a combination that can be particularly difficult to achieve. Ads from Nintendo, Amazon Fire TV, Walmart, Game Stop and Lowe’s effectively captured consumer attention while demonstrating other persuasive components such as Information, Relevance and Desire.

Consumers Thirst for Information

Particularly at this time of year, consumers appreciate simplicity of messages and well-delivered information about a product or offer to help them make informed decisions. Nearly half of all holiday ads featured a special offer including four of the top 15. In addition, winning ads from Nintendo, Ebates, Amazon, Subway, Best Buy and Walmart used a variety of approaches to effectively appeal to the rational, delivering information and inspiring desire.

Celebrity or Santa

Celebrities were featured in nearly 12 percent of all holiday ads. Four ads appeared in the top 15, including Mazda’s “Braedan’s Story,” featuring Minnie Driver, and Walmart’s “Surprise,” featuring Chicago Bears’ Jared Allen. Both of these top ads were likely powered by their philanthropic themes rather than the famous narrators. Likewise, Walmart’s “Unbeatable Prices,” featuring Melissa Joan Hart and Anthony Anderson, and Amazon Fire TV’s “Rom-Coms,” featuring Curt Menefee and Jimmy Johnson, were also arguably powered by the ad’s product offers.

Santa’s presence in this year’s ad set is down 27 percent overall. The big man appeared in 24 of the nearly 400 spots, versus 33 last year, and appears in only one of the top performing 15, having a cameo role in Home Depot’s “Spread More of This.”